Sex, Morality and Epic Fantasy

There is yet one more response to the nihilism in fantasy issue at the Black Gate blog by someone named Theo, who is also the ultra-rightwing blogger Vox Day. Very unsurprisingly, he agrees with Leo Grin’s original point. There are a lot of – to phrase it very politely – strange assertions in this post. The comment thread is good, though. Continue reading →

Posted in Books, Writing | Tagged , , | 15 Comments

Berlin Film Festival

Among all the plagiarism and nihilism discussions, I completely forgot that the jury of the Berlin Film Festival has awarded the golden and silver bears for 2011.

This year was a clean sweep for the Iranian film Jodaeiye Nader az Simin (Nader And Simin, A Separation), which took the golden bear as well as two silver bears in both acting categories and the Prize of the Ecumenical Jury (a related award given by the Catholic and Protestant church).

This is one of the things I like about the Berlin film festival, that the juries tend to award complete outsider films. This year’s winner is actually one of the more mainstream jury decisions, previous winners included a drama about sexual violence from Peru, the first Peruvian film ever to win an award at a major festival, and a retelling of Carmen set in a South African township. The juries at Cannes, Venice, Sundance, etc… usually tend to go with arthouse mainstream and the big names on the festival circuit, but in Berlin completely offbeat films can and do win. Besides, seeing two young women in traditional Islamic garb on stage at a film festival accepting an acting award is just lovely.

The two German entries, Schlafkrankheit (Sleep Sickness) about a German developmental worker in Cameroon and Wer wenn nicht wir (Who if not us) about the RAF (that is Red Army Fraction, not Royal Air Force) as well as a German short film by Konrad Mühe, son of actor Ulrich Mühe, also took home silver bears, which is a suprisingly good showing for German cinema.

No award at all for American cinema, which is unusual, because an American film usually gets a nod in one of the lesser categories to keep the Hollywood stars and directors motivated, so they’ll come back next year. But True Grit, which might have had a chance and was the opening film, did not take part in the competition and was not eligible and the American banking crisis drama which was eligible apparently did not sufficiently impress.

The full list of winners is here.

Posted in Film | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Oh Joy! – Yet more on Plagiarism, Nihilism and Prescriptive Linguists – Oh, Joy!

The spam catcher plug-in I use is normally fairly effective, but it also has its moments of fail. Today, it let through an obvious spam comment (for online shoe shops of all things), while a legitimate comment got caught in the spam trap.

Meanwhile, I have some more links and discussion on the two controversial subjects of the moment behind the cut: Continue reading →

Posted in Books, General, Links | Tagged , , , , , , , | 10 Comments

And now for that other controversial subject

The whole nihilist fantasy debate is still driving a lot of traffic to the site. Yesterday, I had 60 visitors, down from an all-time high of 85 the day before. Today, there have been already 17 visitors.

Related to the recent nihilism in epic fantasy dust-up, Kate Elliott wonders whether women write epic fantasy differently than men. Found via Sherwood Smith, who also weighs in here. Lots of good points in both discussions.

I think an equally interesting question is why, even though there are plenty of women writing epic fantasy and any other kind of fantasy for that matter, are the first names that come to mind always men. Ditto for new weird, slipstream, sword and sorcery, steampunk and pretty much every other subgenre. Only for urban fantasy, the first names that come to mind include women – and even there you’ll find plenty of people, usually male, who only list male urban fantasy authors (the comment thread here is a typical example) and ignore the women. Bonus points if they name male authors who write something other than what is commonly defined as urban fantasy. Double bonus points if the post/comment in question states that those male authors write “good urban fantasy”, unlike the women who only write porn. Triple bonus points if one of the male authors is actually a woman with an ambiguous name.

It’s also telling that none of the examples given for gritty nihilist/realist (depending upon your POV) fantasy was written by a woman. Because women certainly write gritty, nihilist and violent fantasy. In fact, some of the nastiest and most explicit torture scenes I have ever read were written by women. I used to recommend certain female fantasy and SF authors to male readers with “This books has very explicit torture scenes.” Elizabeth Bear, Caitlin Kittredge, Stacia Kane, Karen Miller, Lilith Saintcrow, Tamara Siler Jones, Maria V. Snyder, Rob Thurman, etc… can all be very gritty and depressing on occasion, yet none of them get to join the men in the nihilist conspiracy for the undermining of Tolkien, Howard and all that is good and right in fantasy. Never mind that the explicit sex scenes found in the works of many female fantasy writers would probably be mistaken for one of the signs of the coming apocalypse by the likes of Leo Grin.

Meanwhile, Paul Jessup wonders how urban fantasy would look like from the POV of an ordinary person living in an urban fantasy world. The thing that comes closest to this would probably be Shanna Swendson’s Enchanted Inc. series.

Posted in Books, Research | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Why Plagiarism is a Big Deal

Today, I was at a family birthday dinner. On the plus side, I got to spend some time with a family member in a difficult situation and had an excellent meal of antipasti, pasta with creamy vegetable tomato sauce and a cup of wonderfully rich hot chocolate. On the negative side, I also had to deal with such annoyances as people who had to complain about the choice of restaurant before even a single bite of food had been served* and people who attempt transfer their own eating disorders to young children**.

During the meal, the conversation also touched upon the Guttenberg plagiarism affair. Someone asked me what I thought about the issue and I replied, “Well, it looks bad. He’s going to have to come up with one hell of an explanation to save his degree and himself.”

The other people at the table – well, at least the three in my immediate vicinity – vehemently disagreed. Continue reading →

Posted in General | Tagged , , | 9 Comments

More Plagiarism, More Nihilism, Some Romance and Some Metrics

There is a definite upside to blogging about hot potato subjects like I did in yesterday’s post. Because February 17th, 2011, was the busiest day since the relaunch of the site with 85 visitors altogether according to the WordPress Stats system, even beating out the post about the misappropriation of Leonard Cohen’s Hallelujah (there are a lot of Leonard Cohen fans out there). My most popular post of all time, by the way, is still the post with photos of snowy winter woods.

Also, someone found this blog via the search term “blood piss shit sex stories”. Sorry, fellow, but whatever you’re looking for (and I’m not sure I want to know), it’s not here.

So back to the controversial topics and some new developments:

More on the plagiarism allegations against German secretary of defense Karl Theodor zu Guttenberg from the Süddeutsche Zeitung (in German), The Economist (in English – ignore trollish comments) and The Wall Street Journal (also in English). There also is a Wiki, where users are constantly logging new suspicious passages.

More on the other controversial topic, which actually brought in all of those visitors (you didn’t think anyone cared that much about plagiarism allegations against a German politician most of my readers have probably never heard of, did you?):

More reactions on the nihilism in fantasy dust-up from Scott Andrews, BC Woods, Hippogriff and Lenty’s Blog.

Sam Sykes believes that a fear of innovation lies at the root of such debates and also singles out the silliest and most offensive comment to the original post. Cause you see, it’s the women who are to blame for the debasement of fantasy. Never mind that all of the examples given in the original post were books by men and that gritty epic fantasy as a subgenre tends to be dominated by men.

Talking of which Floor to Ceiling Books wonders “Where are the women in all this?”, a sentiment I can fully get behind. It’s also very telling that the original article praises Robert E. Howard’s heroic fantasy but makes no mention of C.L. Moore, probably because Leo Grin has no idea that she exists. And if Mr Grin ever were to read Jacqueline Carey’s Kushiel series (mentioned in the Floor to Ceiling Books post), he would probably have a fit at all the “depravity and nihilism” on display there.

Cheryl Morgan weighs in as well here and here and also wonders whether responding to obvious troll posts such as Leo Grin’s original post and Martin Amis’ recent dismissal YA writers is worth it at all.

I’d say that drawing attention to such posts is worth it. That and I was too tired and busy yesterday for extensive original content and just threw out a bunch of links, especially since it was a day of many fascinating links. I’m not going to get involved into any discussions called Whatever-fail, though.

Speaking of tired, Theodora Goss has another great post about writing while tired. Her blog is quickly becoming one of my favourites.

In other news, here is a great interview with Mary Bly a.k.a. Eloisa James about romance fiction, genre stigma and anti-romance prejudice and her relationship with her parents from The Southeast Review. Found via All About Romance.

Rose Lemberg has a great posts on why snail mail submission excludes many writers and why electronic submissions are important. I totally agree with this.

Posted in Books, Links | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Plagiarism, Vampires, Nihilist Fantasy and the latest Genre Dust-up

I’m busy with work, but lots of other interesting things happened online and off. Hence, I have lots of links for you today under the cut: Continue reading →

Posted in Books, Research, Writing | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

Ruminations on Mad Men

There have been at least two article of late where a writer explains why he doesn’t like the 1960s advertising industry drama Mad Men. Here’s an appraisal from the New York Review of Books that I linked to before and here is another from the London Review of Books. There’s also a rebuttal from Slate.

Both articles capture many of the issues I have with Mad Men, mainly the “Look at those people. Aren’t they backwards” condescension coupled with the nostalgic “But it sure looks cool, doesn’t it?” longing. And of course, the backwardness and dated attitudes are pointed out so blatantly in the dialogue that all that’s missing is a flashing red arrow. The New York Review of Books writer is absolutely right, all that’s missing are the captions. Continue reading →

Posted in TV | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Book Haul, Romanheft Woes and the Demise of the Cheque

Today, I was at the bank to pay a cheque into my account and had an “Okay, now how does this work again” moment, because I haven’t actually handled a cheque in ages. For something that used to be nigh ubiquitous, cheques died out pretty rapidly, killed off for good by the switch to the Euro in 2002. I don’t even have a chequebook anymore. I don’t think my mother has one, either, and she used to write cheques a lot more than I ever did.

Aside from this observation, I don’t really have a whole lot to say. Though I was in town today and bought a couple of books (and a new sweater). I bought Hotter Than Hell, an urban fantasy anthology edited by Kim Harrison, My Name is Memory by Ann Brashares and Goddess of the Rose by P.C. Cast. Since the success of the House of Night series, P.C. Cast’s older mythologically based novels have been reissued. However, because Cast is now famous as a YA author, her older books seem to be marketed as YA as well, even though they were considered adult fantasy when first published.

What is more, I also picked up The Black Dagger Brotherhood – An Insider’s Guide by J.R. Ward. This is the sort of book I wouldn’t normally be bothering with, if not for the PhD. I’m not the world’s biggest fan of the Black Dagger Brotherhood. But the series is popular and I hope the supplementary material in this one will be useful for the thesis.

On the downside, I still haven’t been able to track down the new “Romanheft” series I’m looking for. The train station newsstand didn’t have it and they had no idea when to expect it, either. Since “Romanhefte” are viewed as disposable and interchangeable reading, it’s very difficult to get accurate information on publication schedules. The staff at newsstands and supermarkets and other places where they’re sold usually have no idea when new “Romanhefte” will be delivered and why anybody would care about a specific series or issue anyway.

Finally, since it’s Valentine’s Day, here is Theodora Goss on different kinds of romantic love and whether they make for good fiction.

I agree with her that the hyper dramatic Tristan and Isolde type love is the most common version on romantic fiction, though it’s not exactly perfectly suited to the modern genre romance with its happily ever after requirement, because Tristan and Isolde does not end happily ever after. When the latest film adaption came out a few years ago, I recall people lamenting that the story did not end happily, which utterly baffled me, because hey, it’s Tristan and Isolde. Surely everybody knows what happens. And anyway, what’s next? Complaining that Romeo and Juliet doesn’t end happily?

But I’m not sure if the third type of love the Theodora Goss describes is really that unsuited to interesting stories. At any rate, that’s the kind of love I am trying to describe in “the novel”. Of course, there’s always the possibility that no one cares but me. But I certainly don’t hope so.

Posted in Books, Research | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

Link Round-up for a Cold and Grey Sunday

The snow is gone by now, but it was cold and grey all day long and turned foggy by night. I even started up the fireplace, which I don’t do all that often.

And now for some links, mainly writing related:

Here is a great article on books, the digital revolution and technological change from Slate. Found via Estara.

Lilith Saintcrow continues her great series on writing fight scenes.

Marissa Day continues her series on writing sex scenes at the Book View Cafe.

Martin Amis proves that he is still a jerk and insults writers of children’s and YA fiction while he’s at it.

Mark Chadbourn discusses the ethics of using actual historical figures as characters in historical fiction at the Pyr Books blog.

I’ve struggled with this myself when writing historicals (whether historical fantasy or straight historical fiction), because to me it seems unethical to misrepresent a person who really lived and who might have living descendants. My solution to the dilemma was to research the person in question thoroughly, so I would be able to say, “Yes, based on the evidence I have, I think this is a reasonably accurate portrayal of this person.”

Posted in Books, Links, Writing | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment