Let’s take a trip back in time. Thirty-seven years ago, in the spring of 1989, Time Inc. merged with Warner Bros. to become the world’s biggest media conglomerate at the time. Pre-Internet, this was the sort of news that normally would only appear in the business section of the newspaper and sixteen-year-old me would likely never have heard of it. At the time, I definitely didn’t read the business section of the newspaper and was only just beginning to pay attention to the studio logos at the start of movies and understand what they meant.
However, sixteen-year-old Cora religiously watched the cultural TV program aspekte, because I assumed that this was what truly cultured people did. And I very much wanted to be a truly cultured person(TM). At the time, aspekte normally focussed on high culture (they still do) and social issues – you’d almost never see a feature about popular culture or even the latest Hollywood movies there. Coincidentally, I only stopped watching aspekte during the covid pandemic, because instead of focussing on the very real and existential issues facing musicians, actors, directors, writers, etc… due to the covid shutdown, they ran umpteen features where some philosopher sprouted nonsense about how covid gave us an important pause for reflection and how deceleration was good for us. This annoyed me so much that I stopped watching a program I had religiously followed for more than thirty years, even when I realised that no matter how hard I tried, I would never be a truly cultured person(TM).
When I tuned into aspekte back in the spring of 1989, I was surprised to find that instead of reports about theater festivals, new opera productions, modern dance and arthouse movies about the shittiness of life made by oppressed directors in developing countries, there was a report about the then newly announced Time Warner merger. That report was very alarmist and worried a lot about Time Warner becoming a media monopoly and how they would determine what we watch, read, etc…, as evidenced by the massive advertising campaign for Tim Burton’s Batman film (which was really inescapable at the time). The spirit of Alfred Hugenberg, Weimar Republic era media mogul and Nazi supporter, was invoked. And no, don’t get me started on how bloody offensive it was to compare a media company founded by Jewish immigrants that gave work and a voice to many refugees from the Nazi terror in the 1930s and 1940s and made anti-Nazi movies before the start of WWII in Europe to a fucking Nazi supporter.
That aspekte episode is long lost to the mists of time, which is a pity, because I’d really love to see it again. However, the report about the Time Warner merger deeply upset me, especially since we’d just learned about Alfred Hugenberg and his role in Hitler’s rise to power at school. In fact, I mainly remember this long ago aspekte episode and how it upset me, because I wrote about it in my diary, worried that Time Warner was trying to control what we would get to watch and read (and private television had come to my little village just a few weeks before, bringing with it a sudden influx of US TV shows that the public stations would not show and a breath of freedom I was terrified to lose again). So far, Time Warner were just trying to ram Batman down our throats (and I didn’t much like Batman), but what if they got their hands on Star Wars or Marvel Comics or Disney or something else I liked (and yes, those were the examples I listed)? What if they would try to keep us from ever watching Star Wars or reading Marvel Comics again? What if the children that came after me would never get to watch a Disney film? What is all we were allowed to watch was Batman until the end of time. Imagine Batman stomping onto a human face forever.
I’m not sure what conclusion, if any, aspekte wanted us to draw from their report about the Time Warner merger. It likely was not the conclusion I drew about the eternal tyranny of Batman. Personally, I suspect that someone at aspekte was a Batman fan and was just looking for an excuse to talk about the Batman movie, especially since they ran a very similar piece (“Batman is dark and serious now and no longer cartoony like the previous version”) minus the Hugenberg alarmism when The Dark Knight came out in 2008. However, I can tell you to what conclusion I came and that was not “Go and watch Batman” (and indeed, I didn’t see Tim Burton’s Batman film, which was actually pretty good for its time, until several years later). Instead, I decided to single-handedly hold back the media kraken that was Time Warner by staging a one person boycott against them. Or rather a two person boycott, since I convinced my friend Dagmar to boycott them as well.
I actually kept my Time Warner boycott up for several years, which wasn’t that difficult at first, since I didn’t read DC Comics anyway – I was a Marvel fan through and through. Boycotting their publishing arm Warner Books wasn’t much of a problem either, since they rarely published anything I wanted to read. The first difficulty I ran into was that I was also a budding cineast and a lot of interesting vintage movies on late night TV bore the hated Warner Bros logo (because Warner Bros was one of the more interesting Hollywood studios of the 1930s and 1940s). I eventually decided that it was okay to watch those, because they were old and it wasn’t as if I was giving Warner Bros any money by watching them on TV. I also wondered why the company that was the modern Hugenberg made so many anti-Nazi films back in the day. I also decided that it was probably okay to read Time Magazine, when someone handed me a free issue on a plane and I didn’t pay for it, English language magazines and newspapers being a rare treasure in those pre-internet days. Cartoons came next, because Warner Bros’ vintage Merry Melodies and Looney Tunes cartoons were really, really good in a way I was only just beginning to appreciate once I started getting the jokes. Plus, there was a time in the mid 1990s when Warner tried to rival Disney’s cartoon imperium with new interpretations of their classic characters, a Warner Studio store chain (and I still felt slightly guilty about buying a charm bracelet with cartoon characters there), Warner movie theme parks (the German one still exists, though without the Warner branding) etc… Though I still didn’t read DC Comics until I went straight to Vertigo also in the mid 1990s. Besides, by that point it was clear that aspekte had been overly alarmist and that we were not facing the eternal tyranny of Batman forever, that Time Warner wasn’t actually trying to suppress anything and that they also weren’t Alfred Hugenberg. Besides, it was increasingly becoming clear by that time that Rupert Murdoch and News Corp/Fox were the ones we should really be concerned about.
Meanwhile, Warner Bros. kept merging with other companies as if it was about to go out of style and was passed from hand to hand like a cursed object. They merged with AOL and then with AT&T and then with Discovery and finally with Skydance Media (not to be confused with other things that are called Skysomething or other) who had gobbled up Paramount previously. Scott Galloway has a summary of the many mergers of Warner Bros. and how it never worked out for whoever acquired Warner Bros. this time. Cause Warner Bros. apparently truly is a cursed object.
But while the alarmism of aspekte was mistaken and completely over-the-top in 1989, the latest two of the many Warner Bros mergers showed hints that what I had been worried about back in 1989 was actually becoming true. Though the media tyranny of Warner Bros. and their latest masters did not manifest as being forced to watch Tim Burton’s Batman forever and ever. No, it was much worse and much more stupid than that.
After Warner Bros. merged with Discovery, a guy named David Zaslav became CEO. No one outside business analysts had ever heard his name before, but within a few months David Zaslav managed to become one of the most hated people in media, when he cancelled the already complete Batgirl movie as well as an almost complete Scooby Doo holiday special called Scoob! Holiday Haunts for tax write-offs, which meant that the movies were shelved and likely deleted unseen. Coyote vs. Acme was only narrowly saved from the same fate, when the rights were acquired by Ketchup Entertainment and went on to became a massive hit, outgrossing Supergirl. Zaslav also cancelled several shows already in green-lit and in production, including a new Batman animated series that was billed as a follow-up to the beloved Batman: The Animated Series of the 1990s. So much for being forced to watch Batman for all eternity. Cause now, even Batman and his associates were no longer safe from cancellation, while Zaslav apparently disliked cartoons and instead wanted to push reality shows and home makeover shows and that sort of stuff.
On the plus side, James Gunn and Peter Safran were made heads of the floundering DC Studios during the Zaslav era and started to turn out several interesting and good movies and TV shows, including the best Superman movie since the first two Christopher Reeve movies, a surprisingly good Green Lantern TV show, a fun Creature Commandos cartoon, some interesting Batman villain solo projects and a Supergirl movie that was hated by the usual jerks, but was actually pretty damn good. And then Warner Bros. was sold again, this time to Skydance Media, who had already gobbled up Paramount and are owned by far right billionaire and failed actor David Ellison. David Zaslav left with a severance payment higher than what most people earn in their lifetime and James Gunn and Peter Safran, who were initially told their jobs were safe, were abruptly fired and replaced by a guy who wants to make Christian superhero movies that appeal to his grandmother and his church.
This led to so much fury and anger that Skydance Media‘s stock market value actually dropped (yes, hit ’em where it hurts), while the eternally deluded Snyder Bros cheered and mistakenly hoped that Saint Zack will come back any day now. Ever opportunistic, Gal Gadot, whose career hasn’t amounted to much in recent years, and – more disappointingly – Henry Cavill, who not only lost the James Bond role to Robert Pattinson, but was never actually in the running for it in the first place, both remarked that they would like to come back as Superman and Wonder Woman respectively.
So in short, the situation was already bad, but then it got worse. Because in order to acquire the cursed object that is Warner Bros., Skydance Media needed a lot of money, more than even a billionaire like David Ellison and his dad Larry Ellison of Oracle have. So they turned to none other than fellow far right billionaire Elon Musk, the man who turns everything he owns to shit (see Tesla, SpaceX and Twitter) and who now owns a significant share in Skydance Media. Ellison has assured that Musk won’t have any influence on what Skydance chooses to produce and that a highly critical documentary about Elon Musk will still be streamed on HBO, which is owned by Skydance, but I’m not holding my breath for how long that non-interference is going to last.
Note that collectively Skydance Media owns Warner Bros, Paramount, HBO, CNN, CBS, nicklelodeon, Discovery, Cartoon Network, MTV, DC Comics, Village Roadshow Pictures and everything they own the rights to, including Star Trek, all DC Comics characters, Looney Tunes, all Hanna Barbera characters, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Transformers (media rights only), Harry Potter (media rights only), Avatar: The Last Airbender, Mission Impossible, The Matrix (and the Wachowski sisters are trying to get the rights back from Warner Bros for obvious reasons) and umpteen others. And knowing that all this is in the hands of two far right Trump supporting billionaires is extremely concerning.
And no, neither David Ellison nor Elon Musk are Alfred Hugenberg. In many worse, they are worse. David Ellison and Ynon Kreiz, who used to be CEO of Mattel before he joined Skydance Media (and who happens to be Israeli), have stated that they will not employ actors, directors and other creatives who have criticised Israel and the War in Gaza. They dress this up in nice language about how Antisemitism has no place in their corporation, but there is a difference between Antisemitism and criticism of Israel. And firing or refusing to hire people based on their political views is wrong. We’ve already seen the impact of this when actress Melissa Barrera was fired from Scream 7 after social media posts criticising the War in Gaza that were deemed “hate speech”. Note that the Scream movies are produced by a Paramount subsidiary, i.e. ultimately by Skydance. Whether you agree with Melissa Barrera or not, she has a right to her opinion and while some of it was phrased badly, it was not hate speech and besides, it’s not as if she’s going to yell “Free Palestine” as she’s chased around by Ghost Face on screen.
More recently, the books of Irish writer Sally Rooney were pulled from sale in the UK due to Rooney’s support for a Pro-Palestinian organisation that is classified as terrorist in the UK. Now I have never liked Sally Rooney or her books and the organisation she supports is genuinely problematic, but she still has a right to her opinion and people still have the right to read her books. Whether you like Melissa Barrera or Sally Rooney and their work and whether you agree with them or not, blacklisting them and other creatives is wrong today just as it was wrong to blacklist actual or suspected Communists during the McCarthy era to save the world from a Communist conspiracy run by Mr. Hooper from Sesame Street, Dr. Zira from Planet of the Apes, Dale Arden from Flash Gordon and Kup from Transformers/Max from Hart to Heart. Coincidentally, this is the coolest Communist conspiracy ever. And yes, it’s totally my head canon that Mr. Hooper secretly runs the Communist conspiracy from his corner shop on Sesame Street and Dale, Zira and Kup are all his agents. Dale is dispatched to Mongo to bring down Ming the Merciless, cause we all know Flash couldn’t find his own backside with a map, Zira is dispatched to bring down the tyranny of the apes and Kup secretly instigated the workers’ revolt that brought down Sentinel Prime and the Functionist Council of Cybertron by whispering some choice words into the ears of Orion Pax a.k.a. Optimus Prime and D-16 a.k.a. Megatron, except that everything went disastrously wrong when Optimus and Megatron started a million-year- civil war that destroyed the planet.
Unlike what I feared as a teenager, the future will not be Batman and nothing but Batman forever and ever. It will be much more stupid and in some ways much worse. We will still get Superman and Batman movies under Skydance, though they will be bland pro-US government stuff. We may get Wonder Woman played by Gal Gadot again and maybe a Green Lantern film starring Hal Jordan that’s closer to the terrible Ryan Reynolds movie than to the excellent Lanterns. Forget anything more obscure than DC‘s biggest guns. We will still get Star Trek, except that it will be explosion heavy space opera with nothing to say like those J.J. Abrams films. We will still get Transformers films, but it will be more pro-military Michael Bay stuff which completely ignores what Transformers used to stand for and why people like them. We will get Harry Potter rebooted again and again, as the child actors age out, and every iteration will be a weak carbon copy of the previous one. We will still get Looney Tunes and Scooby Doo and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, except that they will be strictly for kids with nothing to say and zero adult appeal. And we will get another dozen of those Taylor Sheridan shows, which are apparently hugely popular, though I have never met a single person who watches them. Some of this stuff will be watchable, though it will still feel bland and hollow and AI-heavy. And everything will be a lot whiter and straighter and more male than it used to be.
No, the future is not Batman stomping on a human face forever and all time. It’s the shitty taste of people like David Ellison, Elon Musk, Jeremy Latham, Ynon Kreiz, etc… foisted onto the rest of the world until the cursed object that is Warner Bros. changes hands again.
sending...